It’s always a challenge for a writer to make readers like a character they would probably hate in real life. A while ago, I started watching two TV shows: Dexter and The Shield. At first, I wasn’t particularly interested. Dexter (starring Michael C. Hall) follows a serial killer—but he’s not that bad, right? After all, he only kills criminals. Meanwhile, in The Shield, Vic Mackey (Michael Chiklis) is a detective and leader of the Strike Team, using illegal and brutal methods—but only against those who, in his eyes, deserve it. A serial killer and a corrupt, violent cop—I was skeptical. And now? I’m hooked.
It might seem unsettling, but are they really that bad? Some people argue that killing serial killers or child molesters is justified. Others believe Mackey is simply fighting fire with fire, using the same ruthless tactics as the gangs that rule the streets. Personally, I’m against the death penalty, and corruption is never justifiable—so why do I enjoy watching Dexter and The Shield? The answer lies in the storytelling. These shows excel at making us understand—even sympathize with—their protagonists. Dexter may be a killer, but he tries to mimic human emotions and maintain a seemingly normal life. Mackey is ruthless, but his love for his family is undeniable.
While discussing these shows with friends, some interesting questions came up about modern television. Are today’s TV series a reflection of our times? Does Dexter have the right to act as judge, jury, and executioner? Does The Shield portray an authentic picture of police corruption? And can entertainment push boundaries without accountability, simply because it’s “just” entertainment?
The answers vary from person to person, as I realized during our conversation. Dexter and The Shield may be vastly different from my “vintage” favorites—like The Persuaders and The Prisoner—but when a show is great, it’s great. Sometimes, we just have to appreciate them for what they are.
See you in Portmeirion!
